One of the hardest decisions you'll face as a dementia caregiver is recognizing when your loved one needs 24-hour supervision and care. You've been managing with partial help, maybe a few hours of in-home care or adult day programs, but increasingly you realize that leaving your loved one alone for even short periods is unsafe. Or you're providing round-the-clock care yourself and reaching the breaking point physically and emotionally. The question isn't whether more care is needed, it's when to make the transition and what form that care should take.
The transition to 24-hour care is both practical and emotional. Practically, your loved one's safety and care needs have exceeded what part-time help can provide. Emotionally, admitting you can't do it alone or that your loved one needs institutional care can feel like failure or abandonment, even though it's neither. This decision involves weighing safety against independence, financial resources against quality of care, family capacity against professional expertise, and present reality against future progression.
Here's what to do right now: (1) Honestly assess your loved one's current safety and supervision needs, (2) evaluate whether you or family members can sustainably provide 24-hour care at home, (3) calculate the cost of 24-hour in-home care versus memory care placement, (4) visit memory care facilities to understand what that option looks like, and (5) have a family conversation about realistic options and everyone's capacity to help.
Key Takeaway: Transitioning to 24-hour care isn't giving up on your loved one. It's recognizing that their needs have grown beyond what part-time care can safely provide, and ensuring they receive appropriate supervision and support around the clock. Whether that's in-home care or facility placement depends on safety needs, financial resources, and family circumstances, not on how much you love them.
If you're just beginning to consider this transition, you may want to review our guide on when home care is no longer safe with dementia. For context on how care needs progress, see our article on caregiving for middle-stage dementia, when these decisions often become necessary.
Signs Your Loved One Needs 24-Hour Supervision
Knowing when part-time care is no longer enough requires honest assessment of your loved one's abilities and safety risks. Understanding signs dementia is getting worse helps you recognize when care needs have escalated.
Safety Concerns That Indicate Need for 24-Hour Care
Wandering
- Leaving home and getting lost
- Trying to leave at night or in dangerous weather
- Wandering within the home and falling
- Attempting to drive when they shouldn't
- Opening doors or gates you've secured
Fall Risk
- Frequent falls or near-falls
- Unsteady gait requiring physical support
- Poor judgment about mobility (trying to walk when they can't)
- Getting up at night without help and falling
- Forgetting to use walker or cane
Inability to Manage Emergencies
- Wouldn't know how to respond to fire, intruder, or injury
- Can't use phone to call for help
- Might make situations worse (trying to fix a gas leak)
- Can't follow instructions during emergency
Dangerous Behaviors
- Leaving stove or appliances on
- Forgetting about food cooking
- Smoking unsafely
- Taking wrong medications or doses
- Eating spoiled food or non-food items
- Letting strangers into the home
Medical Needs Requiring Monitoring
- Conditions that could deteriorate quickly without observation
- Frequent medical crises requiring immediate response
- Difficulty recognizing when they're ill or in pain
- Risk of choking requiring supervision during meals
- Seizure risk requiring constant monitoring
Behavioral and Psychological Symptoms
Severe Agitation or Aggression
- Hitting, kicking, or threatening family caregivers
- Destroying property
- Behaviors that endanger self or others
- Aggression that can't be managed safely at home
Severe Paranoia or Hallucinations
- Believing family members intend harm
- Seeing or hearing threatening things
- Behaviors driven by delusions that create danger
- Fear and distress that can't be calmed
Complete Inability to Be Left Alone
If your loved one cannot safely be alone for even 30 minutes while you shower, run to the store, or take a break, you need 24-hour coverage. This isn't about convenience; it's about safety.
Functional Decline Indicating Need for Continuous Care
- Needing help with most or all activities of daily living (bathing, dressing, toileting, eating, moving)
- Requiring two-person assist for transfers or mobility
- Complete incontinence requiring frequent changes
- Inability to communicate needs clearly
- Needing prompting and assistance for every task throughout the day
If you're seeing multiple signs from this list, your loved one likely needs 24-hour care now, not in the future.
The Caregiver's Breaking Point: Recognizing Your Own Limits
Sometimes the need for 24-hour care is driven not by your loved one's condition alone but by the unsustainability of current caregiving arrangements. Many caregivers experience these challenges during middle-stage dementia, when demands intensify dramatically.
Signs You Can't Continue Current Care
Physical Exhaustion
- Sleep deprivation affecting your health and safety
- Physical injuries from lifting, transferring, or restraining your loved one
- Neglecting your own medical conditions
- Frequent illness from stress and exhaustion
- Physical inability to provide the care needed (your loved one is too heavy to lift, too aggressive to manage)
Emotional and Mental Health Deterioration
- Depression or anxiety requiring treatment
- Feeling hopeless, trapped, or resentful constantly
- Having thoughts of harming yourself or your loved one
- Emotional numbness or inability to feel anything
- Crying frequently or feeling overwhelmed daily
Other Relationships Suffering
- Marriage strained to the breaking point
- Neglecting children or grandchildren
- Isolation from friends and support system
- Family conflict over caregiving responsibilities
- Losing connections that sustain you
Work and Financial Consequences
- Unable to maintain employment
- Using all vacation and sick time for caregiving
- Facing job loss or demotion
- Financial strain from lost income and care costs
- Career permanently derailed
Quality of Care Declining
- Making mistakes with medications or care
- Losing patience and snapping at your loved one
- Feeling resentful during care tasks
- Rushing through care or cutting corners
- Knowing your loved one deserves better than you can currently provide
If several of these describe your situation, you've reached or passed your limit. Continuing to push beyond your capacity helps no one. Your loved one needs quality care, and you need to survive this journey with your health and relationships intact. Read our comprehensive articles on signs of caregiver burnout, respite care options, and how to set boundaries as a dementia caregiver.
Recognizing your limits isn't weakness or failure. It's realistic self-assessment and responsible decision-making.
Options for 24-Hour Care: In-Home vs. Facility
Once you've determined 24-hour care is needed, the next question is where that care should be provided. For a comprehensive overview of all care options, see our guide on nursing homes and care options.
Option 1: 24-Hour In-Home Care
This means having professional caregivers in your loved one's home around the clock, either in shifts (typically 8 or 12-hour shifts with different caregivers) or live-in care.
Advantages
- Your loved one stays in familiar environment
- One-on-one attention
- Family has more control over care
- Flexibility in schedule and routines
- Pet can remain with your loved one
Disadvantages
- Very expensive ($10,000 to $20,000+ per month depending on location)
- Requires managing and coordinating multiple caregivers
- Caregiver turnover creates inconsistency
- Limited socialization for your loved one
- Family still heavily involved in oversight and management
- Home may need modifications for safety and accessibility
- Backup plans needed when caregivers call out sick
When In-Home Care Works Best
- Financial resources are sufficient
- Home is suitable for care needs
- Your loved one strongly prefers home setting
- Medical needs are manageable by non-medical caregivers
- Family can oversee care and coordinate caregivers
- Your loved one benefits from familiar environment more than socialization
Option 2: Memory Care Facility
Memory care units within assisted living or dedicated memory care facilities provide 24-hour supervision in secure environments designed for people with dementia.
Advantages
- 24-hour trained staff always present
- Structured activities and socialization
- Purpose-built environment (safe, secure, dementia-friendly)
- No caregiver management for family
- Backup staff when someone calls out
- Often less expensive than 24-hour in-home care ($5,000 to $8,000+ per month depending on location)
- Medical oversight and coordination
- Respite for family caregivers
Disadvantages
- Loss of familiar home environment
- Less one-on-one attention
- Adjustment period can be difficult
- Less control over daily routines
- Concerns about quality of care in some facilities
- Emotional difficulty of placement for family
When Memory Care Works Best
- Your loved one needs secure environment due to wandering
- Behavioral symptoms require specialized intervention
- Socialization and activities benefit your loved one
- Family can't sustainably manage 24-hour care at home
- Cost is more manageable than in-home care
- Physical care needs require professional staff
- Your loved one would be isolated at home
Option 3: Skilled Nursing Facility
For advanced dementia with significant medical needs, skilled nursing provides 24-hour nursing care.
When skilled nursing is appropriate:
- Significant medical needs requiring nursing (not just custodial care)
- Advanced physical decline (bed-bound, difficulty swallowing, frequent infections)
- Need for rehabilitation after hospitalization
- Late-stage dementia requiring total care (see our guide on planning for late-stage dementia and hospice)
Option 4: Family Providing 24-Hour Care
Some families rotate care among multiple family members to provide 24-hour coverage at home without paid caregivers. For guidance on family coordination, see our article on how to coordinate a dementia care team.
When This Works
- Multiple family members available and willing
- Everyone's health and circumstances allow participation
- Clear agreements about schedules and responsibilities
- Realistic about long-term sustainability
- Financial resources don't allow paid care
When This Doesn't Work
- One or two family members bearing disproportionate burden
- Family members have health issues preventing care
- Work and other responsibilities make participation impossible
- Resentment and conflict emerging
- Care quality suffering from exhaustion
Be honest about whether family-only care is sustainable beyond the short term. Many families start with this arrangement and later realize paid help or placement is necessary.
Financial Considerations for 24-Hour Care
Cost is a major factor in deciding how to provide 24-hour care. Understanding your options and resources is essential. For comprehensive guidance, see our article on financial planning for dementia care.
Comparing Costs
24-Hour In-Home Care
- Live-in caregiver: $10,000 to $15,000 per month
- Shift caregivers (24/7 coverage): $15,000 to $25,000+ per month
- Costs vary dramatically by location and agency
Memory Care Facility
- $5,000 to $10,000+ per month depending on location and level of care
- Often includes room, meals, activities, and basic care
- Additional fees for higher care levels or specialized services
Skilled Nursing Facility
- $8,000 to $12,000+ per month
- Medicare covers short-term stays (up to 100 days after hospitalization)
- Medicaid covers long-term stays if eligible
Funding Sources
Private Pay
Using savings, retirement funds, income, and assets to pay for care. Many families pay privately for months or years before transitioning to other funding sources.
Long-Term Care Insurance
If your loved one has a policy, file a claim and use benefits to offset costs. Understand daily benefit limits and benefit period duration. For detailed guidance, see our article on long-term care insurance and dementia.
Veterans Benefits
Aid and Attendance benefits can provide up to $2,295 monthly for veterans or $1,244 for surviving spouses to help pay for care. See our guide on veterans benefits for dementia care.
Medicaid
Covers nursing home care and some home and community-based services for those with limited income and assets. Requires spend-down in most cases. Memory care coverage varies by state. For comprehensive information, see our article on Medicaid planning for dementia care.
Combining Resources
Many families use multiple funding sources over time: private pay initially, then long-term care insurance until benefits exhaust, then Medicaid. Strategic financial planning early helps maximize resources.
Making the Financial Decision
Calculate how long your loved one's resources will last with each option. Factor in that care needs (and costs) will likely increase over time. Consider quality of care and quality of life, not just cost. Sometimes the less expensive option provides better outcomes.
Work with an elder law attorney (see our guide on how to find an elder law attorney for dementia) and financial advisor to understand the financial implications of each option and how to structure spending to preserve resources while ensuring good care.
How to Choose a Memory Care Facility
If facility placement is the right option, choosing where your loved one will live is critical.
What to Look for in Memory Care
Safety and Security
- Secured unit preventing wandering
- Safe outdoor spaces
- Call systems in rooms
- Well-lit hallways and common areas
- Minimal trip hazards
- Emergency response systems
Staff Quality and Training
- Staff trained specifically in dementia care
- Low staff turnover (ask about average tenure)
- Adequate staffing ratios (at least one staff per 6-8 residents during day)
- Caregivers who seem compassionate and patient
- Management responsive and accessible
Environment
- Clean, well-maintained, and odor-free
- Homelike rather than institutional feel
- Clear signage and wayfinding cues
- Residents' rooms personalized
- Common areas inviting and well-used
Activities and Engagement
- Structured daily activities appropriate for various cognitive levels
- Activities happening during your visit (not just on paper)
- Residents engaged and supervised, not parked in front of TV
- Opportunities for exercise, music, art, outings
Quality Indicators
- Good online reviews and reputation
- No recent citations or complaints with state (check state database)
- Families of current residents speak positively
- Residents appear clean, well-groomed, and content
- Meals look appetizing and residents are eating
Questions to Ask
- "What is your staff-to-resident ratio during day, evening, and night shifts?"
- "How do you handle residents who wander or become agitated?"
- "What happens if my loved one's needs increase beyond what you can provide?"
- "How do you communicate with families about changes or concerns?"
- "Can I visit any time, or are there restricted visiting hours?"
- "What activities do you offer, and how do you adapt them for different ability levels?"
- "How do you handle medication management?"
- "What's your staff training program for dementia care?"
Trust Your Instincts
If something feels off during a visit, trust that feeling. This is where your loved one will live, potentially for years. You should feel confident they'll be safe and cared for with dignity.
Visit multiple facilities, visit at different times of day, and visit unannounced if possible to see typical operations, not just the tour version.
Making the Transition: Timing and Process
Once you've decided on 24-hour care and chosen a setting, the transition requires careful planning.
Timing the Transition
Sooner Rather Than Later Often Works Better
- Your loved one adapts more easily in earlier stages when they have more cognitive flexibility
- Waiting until a crisis forces immediate placement is more traumatic
- Planned transitions allow you to choose the best option rather than accepting whatever has availability
Common Timing Mistakes
- Waiting until you're completely burned out
- Waiting until a fall, hospitalization, or crisis forces emergency placement
- Assuming you can manage "just a little longer" repeatedly
- Not recognizing gradual decline until it's severe
How to Transition
For Memory Care Placement
Involve your loved one if possible:
In early to middle stages, some people with dementia can participate in visiting facilities and expressing preferences. Include them if they can handle it without excessive anxiety.
Frame positively:
"We found a place where you'll have friends and activities" rather than "We can't take care of you anymore." For comprehensive guidance on these conversations, see our articles on how to talk to family about moving to memory care and how to tell someone with dementia they are moving.
Use therapeutic fibs if needed:
If your loved one asks why they're moving, sometimes "The doctor thinks this is best" or "We're going to try this for a while" is kinder than detailed explanations they won't remember or understand.
Bring familiar items:
Photos, favorite blanket, chair, or other meaningful items help the space feel less foreign.
Visit regularly, especially early on:
Frequent visits during the first few weeks help with adjustment, though some facilities recommend limiting visits initially if your loved one becomes more agitated after you leave.
Give it time:
The first days or weeks are often difficult. Your loved one may be angry, confused, or trying to leave. This usually improves as they adjust. Most people adapt within 2 to 6 weeks.
Communicate with staff:
Share information about your loved one's routines, preferences, triggers, and what calms them. The more staff know, the better they can provide individualized care.
For In-Home Care
- Introduce caregivers gradually: Have new caregivers shadow current caregivers or family before taking over independently. This builds trust and allows observation of routines.
- Maintain routines: Keep as much consistency as possible in daily schedules, meal times, and activities.
- Communicate clearly: Provide detailed care instructions, information about preferences and routines, emergency contacts, and medical information.
- Monitor quality: Especially initially, be present during care or check in frequently to ensure caregivers are providing good care and your loved one is accepting help.
Addressing Guilt and Emotional Challenges
Transitioning to 24-hour care, especially facility placement, often triggers intense guilt, even when it's clearly the right decision.
Common Guilt-Inducing Thoughts
- "I promised I'd never put them in a home."
- "If I really loved them, I'd find a way to care for them at home."
- "They took care of me; I should be able to take care of them."
- "Other families manage; why can't I?"
- "They're going to feel abandoned."
The Reality
- Promises made before understanding the reality of dementia care don't account for how difficult and dangerous the situation can become.
- Loving someone means ensuring they get the care they need, even if you can't personally provide it all yourself.
- Caring for a parent is fundamentally different from how they cared for you as a child, and 24-hour dementia care exceeds what one person can safely provide. See our articles on helping a parent after dementia diagnosis and helping a spouse after dementia diagnosis for relationship-specific guidance.
- Every family's situation is different; comparing yourself to others isn't helpful.
- Your loved one needs safety, proper care, and supervision, which placement can provide.
What Helps with Guilt
Reframe the decision:
You're not abandoning them; you're ensuring they receive proper care and supervision.
Focus on quality of life:
In a good facility, your loved one may have better quality of life through activities, socialization, and professional care than they would isolated at home.
Remember your loved one when they were healthy:
Would they want you to destroy your health and life to provide care? Most people wouldn't want that for their children or spouse. For guidance on managing these emotions, see our article on how to take a break from caregiving without guilt.
Talk to others who've made this decision:
Support groups for caregivers help you realize guilt is normal and that you're making a responsible, loving choice.
Stay involved after placement:
You're still the advocate, the family, the person who loves them. Placement doesn't end your role; it changes it to something sustainable.
Give yourself grace:
You've done your best in an impossible situation. That's enough.
Guilt will likely linger, but it shouldn't drive decisions. Your loved one's safety and your health are what matter most.
How CareThru Can Help with the Transition to 24-Hour Care
Transitioning to 24-hour care involves coordinating caregivers, communicating with facilities, organizing medical information, and keeping family informed. CareThru helps manage this complex process. For more on using technology effectively, see our guide on using technology to organize dementia care.
Document your loved one's routines, preferences, triggers, and care needs. Share this information with new caregivers or facility staff so they understand how to provide personalized care from day one.
Store all medical information, medication lists, and important documents in CareThru where facility staff or home caregivers can access them. This ensures continuity of care and prevents important information from getting lost during the transition.
Coordinate communication with family members through CareThru during and after the transition. Share updates about how your loved one is adjusting, what you're observing, and how everyone can help.
Track the transition process using CareThru's task management features. From visiting facilities to completing admission paperwork to coordinating the move, keeping organized reduces stress during an already difficult time.
After the transition, use CareThru to log visits, communicate with facility staff, track any concerns, and maintain your connection to your loved one's care even when you're not providing hands-on help.
Frequently Asked Questions About Transitioning to 24-Hour Care
How do I know if it's really time for 24-hour care?
If your loved one cannot safely be alone for even short periods due to wandering, falls, dangerous behaviors, or inability to respond to emergencies, it's time. If you're providing round-the-clock care and experiencing severe physical exhaustion, health problems, or emotional breakdown, it's time. When part-time care no longer ensures safety and wellbeing for your loved one or you, 24-hour care is needed.
Is memory care better than 24-hour in-home care?
It depends on individual circumstances. Memory care provides trained staff, secure environment, socialization, and activities, often at lower cost than 24-hour in-home care. In-home care provides familiar environment and one-on-one attention but requires family oversight and is very expensive. Consider your loved one's needs, your family's capacity, and financial resources. Neither is inherently better; the right choice depends on your situation.
How much does 24-hour care cost?
Memory care facilities typically cost $5,000 to $10,000+ per month depending on location. 24-hour in-home care costs $10,000 to $25,000+ per month depending on whether it's live-in care or shift caregivers. Skilled nursing facilities cost $8,000 to $12,000+ per month. Costs vary dramatically by geographic location, with major metropolitan areas significantly more expensive than rural areas.
Will my loved one adjust to memory care placement?
Most people adjust within 2 to 6 weeks, though the initial transition is often difficult. Your loved one may be confused, angry, or try to leave initially. This usually improves as routines become familiar and they form connections with staff. Visiting regularly (but not so frequently that it prevents adjustment), bringing familiar items, and giving it time helps. Some people never fully adjust, but most do.
Can I bring my loved one home if placement doesn't work out?
Yes, placement isn't permanent unless you want it to be. If your loved one truly isn't adjusting after giving it adequate time, or if the facility isn't meeting their needs, you can make other arrangements. However, be realistic about whether returning home solves the underlying problems that led to placement. Sometimes trying a different facility is better than returning to an unsustainable home situation.
How do I choose between multiple memory care facilities?
Visit each facility multiple times at different times of day. Trust your instincts about where your loved one would be safest and most comfortable. Consider staff quality and demeanor, cleanliness and environment, activities and engagement, other residents' condition and contentment, and family reviews. Ask detailed questions about staffing ratios, training, and how they handle challenging behaviors. Choose based on quality and fit, not just cost.
What if I can't afford 24-hour care?
Explore all funding options: Medicaid (for those with limited income and assets), veterans benefits (Aid and Attendance), long-term care insurance if your loved one has it, and state and local programs that may offer home care assistance or respite. Consult with an elder law attorney about Medicaid planning. Some families combine resources (siblings contributing, selling your loved one's home, spending down assets in planned ways).
Should I tell my loved one the truth about why they're moving to memory care?
This depends on their cognitive level and how they'll likely respond. For some people, honest explanation makes sense. For others, therapeutic fibs ("The doctor recommended this," "We're going to try this," "Your apartment needs repairs") are kinder than explanations they won't remember or understand. The goal is to reduce anxiety and resistance while maintaining dignity. Consult with the facility's staff about best approaches for your loved one's situation. For more on communication, see our guide on how to talk to someone about their dementia diagnosis.
Disclaimer: This article provides general information about transitioning to 24-hour care for dementia and is not a substitute for medical, legal, or financial advice. Every person's situation is unique. Consult with healthcare providers, elder law attorneys, and financial advisors for guidance specific to your circumstances.
Related Articles
When Home Care Is No Longer Safe with Dementia
Recognizing when your loved one can no longer safely remain at home
Nursing Homes and Care Options
Understanding all available care options for dementia
Caregiving for Middle-Stage Dementia
Managing the most demanding phase of dementia caregiving
Financial Planning for Dementia Care
Understanding costs and funding sources for long-term care
Organize the Transition with CareThru
Coordinate care, share information with facilities and caregivers, and keep your family informed during this important transition
Get Started with CareThru